Wednesday, 10 April 2013

It's Heather Beetle time again!


The first heather beetle sighting report in 2013 has been received - at Blackheath in Surrey on 7 April 2013.  Thank you to Sheenagh McLaren, who also took this great photograph of the beetle she spotted.

While Surrey might not be the first place you would look to find heather beetles, it does show that they are not confined to large expanses of moorland.  Those with long memories may remember that the first sighting I received last year from the island of Colonsay on the West Coast of Scotland.  My view is that heather beetles live everywhere where there is heather, but I do not know, and no-one does, what causes the population to bloom to plague proportions, which results in the extensive areas of damage that we are all too familiar with.

Where there is one heather beetle, there are likely to be others and I would be delighted to receive more reports.  Please keep your eyes open.

I will be using this report to kick start the annual survey of heather beetle and will be publishing the details I receive on the Trust's website.  See the dedicated Heather Beetle page for more information about this threat to heather.

Wildfire - and now Dartmoor

Fire on Chat Tor, Dartmoor. Photo: BBC News
Although rather after the event, I think it worth recording that it is not only Scotland and Wales that have suffered this year.  Dartmoor has had a large-scale incident on Chat Tor.  See the BBC News report.  It is interesting to note the the report mentioned that 100 firefighters used beaters to control the fire which extended to 1,482 acres.  I hope this part of the report was inaccurate that the Devon FRS can provide less stone age equipment for its firefighters.

This incident will add some spice to the discussion at the meeting of the England & Wales Wildfire Forum that I am attending on Friday.

Hopefully with the forecast change in the weather this will be the last incident report in this blog for a time, but this watershed marks the shift from talking about fires to thinking about the lessons that can be learned from the incidents up and down the country.  I think it is important to start this process quickly before the rain settles the ash and the smell of burnt vegetation washes out of firefighters hair. It will be too late to consider the lessons in the summer, when life has moved on.

I will post a few ideas onto this blog in the next few days to see if this produces some response.

Monday, 8 April 2013

England: Hill farmers receive more than £2m in Uplands payments

In some good news for upland farmers in England, the Rural Payments Agency has said it paid out more than £2m to beef and sheep farmers eligible for Uplands Transitional Payments within three weeks of the payments starting.

The Uplands Transitional Payment (UTP) provides support to beef and sheep producers in England’s Severely Disadvantaged Areas (SDA) who are managing land in an Environmentally Sensitive Areas (ESA) and/or Countryside Stewardship Scheme (CSS) agreement and previously claimed Hill Farm Allowance (HFA).

The Uplands Transitional Payment is made to Hill Farm Allowance claimants in 2010 who cannot yet enter the replacement scheme, Uplands Entry Level Stewardship because of an existing agreement under the Environmentally Sensitive Areas and/or Countryside Stewardship Scheme.

Up to Wednesday 27 March, the government agency said it had made payments to 925 farmers. This is equivalent to 73% of those eligible for money and more than 67% of the total value of the scheme being paid.  

This appears to be impressive, but should the RPA be satisfied with 73% in three weeks?  How long will it take to pay the remainder?

Members' Briefings: Phytophthora diseases

Phytophthora & Blaeberry
This range of diseases has been shown to have a major impact on larch trees and I have concerns that it is possible that one of the variants might be found to attack dwarf shrubs on moorland.  There has been some impact on blaeberry / bilberry Vaccinium myrtillis but attacks have not been found to be widespread.  Best indications are that heather will be safe from the phytophthora diseases but I think we need to keep a close eye on these diseases.

To find out more, and to learn how to pronounce the name, read the Members' Briefing that is available from the Reading Room on the Trust's website.

This is the fourth in the series and these briefings are available for everyone, but if you are not a member a payment of £40 p.a. would correct this  - more details here.

Sunday, 7 April 2013

Wildfire - 'the headlines don't help'

Photo: Andy Law
We may not be out of the woods yet with this year's wildfire season, but at least we appear to have reached a pause in proceedings. BBC News has published an article, which attempts to get behind the scenes and starts to draw some conclusions.

The Scottish Crofting Foundation is quoted amongst other rhetoric that seeks to spread the cause far and wide, and even includes a reference to sheep ticks. It is good to hear someone extolling the virtues of muirburn from a practical viewpoint - well done the SCF. But maybe, the BBC approach is getting closer to the truth: there is no single cause of the wildfire problems, this year, and there is no single person or group of people to blame. Thrashing around looking for someone to blame will not help, and sensational headlines will not solve the problem.

I think we need to take this opportunity to start thinking about wildfire as a regular feature of moorland and upland management.  We should move beyond the shock-horror response when it occurs, as if it is not expected. We should take the view that wildfire is likely to occur, and plan for it, rather than being caught on the back foot every time it happens.

I have been giving some thought to how the review of the Muirburn Code can address some of the issues that had been highlighted by the recent events. Perhaps we can start a discussion that will help feed into the review process. I have started drafting the report from the Critique Phase of the review of the Code, and I would welcome ideas from anyone who has a view on how the revised Code can be made relevant and useful for wildfire events, as well as muirburn.

£1m to restore peatlands - Wessenden Moor, Yorkshire


This is another example of a water company working with a landowner and Natural England to deliver benefits from better management of peat, including re-vegetating bare peat and raising water levels.  See the article in the Yorkshire Post for more detail.

Wessenden Moor is an area I know well, as it was one of the four moors in the Demonstration Moors Project that the Trust ran for Defra in the five years to 2006.  The moor is a large open area of moorland above Marsden in Yorkshire, at the very northern edge of the Peak District National Park.  It would be defined mostly as a blanket bog.  Much of the peat surface had been eroded and work was underway to revegetate is when I was last there a few years ago.

The photos show a typical area of eroded peat with much bare peat on show, and area where heather brash has been spread to start the re-vegetation process and a general view over the moor.

This type of work has to be good news all round; it will: make the ground more productive, stabilise the eroding peat surface, improve the quality of the water coming off the moor into Yorkshire Water's reservoirs, improve biodiversity and improve the look of the moor for the large number of visitors to the area.

Friday, 5 April 2013

Wildfires in NW Scotland - update


The Scottish Fire & Rescue Service has issued a press release to confirm that all wildfires have now been extinguished and comments that this has only been achieved after an enormous amount of blood, sweat and tears by firefighters.  Well done all!

The press release includes a caution that muirburn should only be undertaken with very close attention to safety procedures, having first carried out a risk assessment. The FRS press release can be downloaded from the FRS website.

Understandably in the circumstances, the value of muirburn has been questioned and fingers have been pointed at those who have been lighting fires. In response to these issues,  I was pleased to hear that Michael Bruce, a landowner, member of The Heather Trust and Chairman of the South Grampian Wildfire Group met with Robert Scott, from the Scottish Fire & Rescue Service this afternoon. Following this meeting a statement has been agreed with Scottish Land & Estates as follows:

LANDOWNERS WELCOME CONSTRUCTIVE TALKS WITH FIRE SERVICE

Landowners from the North and North-east of Scotland have held ‘very constructive’ talks with the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service following the widespread outbreak of wildfires.

Michael Bruce, chairman of the South Grampian Wildfire Group and owner of Glen Tanar Estate, met Robert Scott, Assistant Chief Officer for the North Service Delivery Area, and his assistant, Andy Coueslant, North of Scotland Area Coordinator, today.

Mr Bruce said: “We had an excellent meeting and there is no doubt that now landowners who have been involved in efforts to tackle these wildfires are on the same page as the fire service. We welcome Mr Scott’s recognition of the role that landowners and land managers play in dealing with these fires and there is a real commitment to work together in future. As an example, a call for help in the Highlands earlier this week resulted in local landowners offering to provide 10 specialist fire fogging All Terrain Vehicles that could be used in fire-fighting operations, within 10 minutes. That is the kind of response we offer and criticism of landowners earlier this week from some quarters was unwarranted. We have agreed with the fire service to revitalise the work of the Scottish Wildfire Forum, which has been a key focus for partnership working on wildfire issues since 2004.”


This is good, positive stuff and I hope that it will lead to lessons being learned, and applied, as the result of these wildfire incidents. We need to keep matters in balance and make sure that we do not end up with a result that will lead to less muirburn and an increased risk of damaging wildfire.

Welcome to Natural Resources Wales


This new public body became operational in Wales on 1 April and brings together the work of the Countryside Council for Wales, Environment Agency Wales and Forestry Commission Wales, as well as some functions of Welsh Government.  It will consider social, environmental and economic benefits in the way it manages natural resources and improves the environment.

But will it make a difference?  There are bound to be considerable teething problems as the new body settles down and people get used to working across sectors.  Inevitably, in this day and age, one of the limiting factors will be IT - how long will it take the systems from three separate organisations to learn to communicate?

There has to be logic, which the 'change managers' will have hooked onto, in bringing three organisations together and no doubt there will be a slimming down of 'back-office' staff but it will remain to be seen how this impacts on the moorlands and uplands of Wales.  To my mind these areas of Wales are in serious need of a champion and the test for the new organisation will not be in how sweetly the organisation runs, the amount of paperclips it uses or the size of the cost savings, but the impact it has on the land and on the people that manage the land.  

This model of large single bodies is being considered elsewhere.  In Scotland, will SEPA merge with SNH, in England will Natural England, merge with the Environment Agency or the Forestry Commission?  Natural England is still suffering birth pains from its formation from English Nature, RDS and the Countryside Commission, and it is far from a foregone conclusion that merging organisations is a recipe for instant success.

Natural Resources Wales claims that it will provide a better service for people and businesses as they will now deal with one single body rather than three.  I give a cautious welcome to Natural Resources Wales but from my perspective the jury will be out until the impact on the moorland and upland areas of Wales can be judged.

Thursday, 4 April 2013

SL&E press release: Landowners ready and willing to tackle wildfires



PRESS RELEASE
4 April 2013

LANDOWNERS READY AND WILLING TO TACKLE WILDFIRES

Scottish Land & Estates, which represents 2,500 landowners across Scotland, said today its members were ready, willing and able to assist efforts to tackle wildfires and were being blamed unfairly for the blaze outbreaks.

Luke Borwick, chairman of Scottish Land & Estates, said landowners are responsible citizens with the specialist equipment, funding and willingness to help tackle wildfires voluntarily.

Mr Borwick said: “The private sector remains ready and well-resourced to help and can be mobilised at a moment’s notice, however it is disappointing to hear how our landowning members are being unfairly blamed for this situation.

“We are now are calling on organisations such as the NFU Scotland, the Scottish Crofting Federation and the Scottish Tenant Farmers Association (STFA) to ensure that their members assist the fire service in controlling the flames that continue to burn in the Western Highlands. 

He continued: “Scottish Land & Estates was instrumental in the development of the Muirburn Code, along with other organisations such as the Association of Deer Management Groups, which has existed for several years and our members are well used to adhering strictly to the code.

“Contingency plans created by Scottish Land & Estates and other organisations, on the back of the bad fire season in 2011 have been initiated and we have offered support to the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service. We have members near the fires ready to volunteer their resources to help.

“Muirburn is an essential form of hill farm and Highland land management enabling grass and heather regeneration but must be exercised with caution at all times. Some of these fires have been as a result of careless activity by recreational access takers. However, a significant number of fires have clearly been the result of irresponsible actions of other land users burning and not following the Muirburn Code.

“We agree with the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service’s call for muirburn restrictions, but any restriction should only be targeted on high risk areas in the west and not applied uniformly across the country.  The Eastern Highlands for example in many places are still blanketed in snow, and controlled burning will still be safe, as the snow retreats, for some time there.”

ENDS

NOTES TO EDITORS
Scottish Land & Estates published a comprehensive wildfires guide in February last year, following a survey which showed that 96% of its members were willing to participate in creating a chain of wildfire defence, by working with the Fire and Rescue Services and their rural neighbours.   The guide also responds to calls being made for contingency plans to be put in place by rural groups in all high risk areas, in an effort to tackle the threat of wildfires ahead of the dry season.

For further information:-
Ramsay Smith
Media House
m: 0141 220 6040 / 07788 414 856

Wednesday, 3 April 2013

Wildfires in NW Scotland - Request to stop Muirburn

Photo: Karen Appleyard
The Scottish Fire & Rescue Service has issued a request for all land managers (crofters, farmers, gamekeepers & stalkers) in NW Scotland to stop all muirburn activities in response to the continuing spate of wildfires.

It is inconceivable that anyone in this area where conditions are so dry should be considering muirburn, as it is clear that any fire once established will be difficult, if not impossible, to control.  However, this does not mean that muirburn cannot be carried out in other parts of Scotland, especially where snow is still lying, but great care must be exercised; conditions can be deceptively dry even in between beds of snow.

The Fire Service is at full stretch fighting the existing wildfires in NW Scotland, and no-one should consider adding to the workload of permanent and part-time crews.  It will be difficult for the Fire Service to maintain this level of activity and with the weather set to remain the same until early next week, there are concerns about how the Service will cope.

As an example of the scale of the problem, I spoke to a senior fire officer this evening, who told me that one of the fires had a front that extended over 8km, it was being attacked by two helicopters with water bombing equipment and numerous fire engines had been deployed to protect property.

This evening the Fire Service reported that in the Highlands & Islands area, fire crews had attended almost 200 wildfire incidents during the last week and there were 6 large wildfire incidents in progress:

Braeintra/Achmore
  • Nine appliances were in attendance dealing with a significant wildfire incidents and were being assisted by a helicopter. 
Tornapress/Kishorn
  • Four appliances were attendance with assistance from a helicopter. 
Glenfinnan
  • Four appliances were dealing with this wildfire incident. 
Ty-Coat, Kinlochmoidart
  • Two appliances were in attendance. 
Invergarry
  • One appliance was in attendance. 
Stratton Lodge Area
  • One appliance was in attendance.

Tuesday, 2 April 2013

Wildfire & Muirburn - Radio Scotland interview

Photo: Greg Little
I was interviewed for the Newsdrive programme on Radio Scotland this afternoon.  You can listen to the interview on the iPlayer - coverage starts at 37:29 and continues until 45:25.  The interview will be available for 7 days, until 9 April.

The thrust that landowners do all the burning and that all the fires are escaped muirburn fires was interesting.  The suggestion that muirburn was all connected with grouse moor management was also an indication of the perceptions with the Fire & Rescue Service and the BBC.  I do not think that the Fort William area is renowned for its grouse shooting.

My interview was recorded and therefore I was not aware of the views that had been expressed in the earlier part of the article.  This perception of who carries out muirburn is an interesting issue and is something I will need to take into account in leading the review of the Muirburn Code and its subsequent promotion. There is a danger that in looking to explain this perception, the conclusion will be reached that this is an attack on grouse moor management. However, could an alternative explanation be that the interviewer simply did not know any better and thought that muirburn was only carried out as part of grouse moor management? There might be a wider perception issue to address.

I do not have any information to confirm my view, but I would expect that the amount of moorland / hill burnt for farming or deer purposes is a significant percentage of the area burnt for grouse, even if it does not exceed it. Therefore, to place all the 'blame' for wildfire at the door of landowners interested in grouse moor management is an error.

There is no doubt that any fire that gets out of control is unfortunate, but we must accept that it will happen. I would like to see the review of the Muirburn Code placing a greater emphasis on reducing the number of out of control fires resulting from prescribed burning.  This could be achieved by improving the level of training both through transferred experience and by increasing the  understanding of fire behaviour.

Liaison with the Scottish Fire Service should also be increased through a re-envigorated Scottish Wildfire Forum.  The Forum should seek to link the experience of fire fighting in the Scottish FRS with the experience of prescribed burning available within the land management sector. The two are complementary, especially when the use of suppression fires is considered - using fire to fight fire.

Wildfire Incidents - Highlands & Islands

Photo: Greg Little
There are an increasing number of wildfires in the Highlands & Islands of Scotland.  The Scottish Fire & Rescue service (a single fire service since, yesterday) has reported that at 12:30 today they were tackling 6 wildfires:

Banavie near Fort William
  • The wildfire at Banavie has been extinguished and is under control. Crews are in attendance to maintain a watching brief and check for any hot spots. 
  • At its height, there was a 3 mile fire front with 8 appliances and 50 personnel who worked throughout the night to control the fire. 
Morar near Mallaig
  • There is currently a large fire front with and crews in attendance who are making good progress in dealing with this heath and moorland fire. 
Gairloch
  • There is a significant fire with crews in attendance currently assessing the risk to property with an Officer mobilised to assist in the incident management. 
Glenfinnan
  • There is a heath and moorland fire in the hills around this area. Crews are assessing the wildfire and the risk to properties in the area. 
Lochinver
  • The wildfire at Lochinver is under control. Crews remain in attendance to monitor the incident. 
Kishorn
  • There is an ongoing wildfire with crews in attendance to deal with the incident.
I was near Oban yesterday and can confirm that conditions were very, very dry.  I expect that the conditions further north are as bad if not drier.  The easterly wind was very blustery, which would make it very difficult to predict the behaviour of a fire.  

At the risk of generalising, but based on the conditions I saw, and these wildfire reports, I think it most unlikely that conditions are suitable for muirburn anywhere in the north and west of Scotland.  Great caution must be exercised before lighting fires for any purpose.  

Friday, 29 March 2013

Wildfire risk high in NW Scotland

Photo: Greg Little
Many areas are still struggling to recover from snow drifts but according to a BBC report, north-west Scotland escaped the snow and the dry conditions have resulted in a spate of wildfires.

The main muirburn season extends until 15 April, but anyone planning muirburn in NW Scotland is advised to exercise great caution.  Conditions may be too dry and it would be difficult or impossible to control a fire after it has started.

Better Outcomes on Upland Commons

Photo: National Centre for the Uplands
I was pleased to have been invited to support a new initiative covering Upland Commons, that has been established following concerns raised by HRH The Prince of Wales.




The recently established National Centre for the Uplands, which is based at Newton Rigg College in Penrith, has established a partnership of organisations to provide input to the work.  The main focus of the initiative will be to establish how best to combine the many and various interests in upland commons. The work will  include a consideration of: the practical and business needs of farmers (for example in sheep stocking levels), improvements to water retention and quality, maintenance of the cultural landscape and how to accommodate public access.

I was present at a launch meeting in Sedbergh, yesterday, that Prince Charles attended, and there was a good discussion amongst the organisations represented at the meeting about how the initiative can best achieve its objectives.

This work plays very much to The Heather Trust's agenda of seeking to develop cross-sector consensus to improve the management of moorland and upland areas, while embracing the views of a large range of organisations that have potentially conflicting requirements. However, as we have found in many other projects, to allow progress to be made all views must be respected and areas of agreement identified.  I am sure we will find that it will be possible to reach agreement on about 90% of the issues, but it will be important not to let the remaining 10% derail progress.

The initiative will be considering case studies from a range of upland commons across England looking for a range of aspirations, circumstances, problems and existing progress. I think it will be interesting to look at places where partnership working has been established, and compare this with areas where this has yet to be achieved. The work I co-ordinated for Scotland's Moorland Forum for the Upland Solutions project has similarities and it is possible that the report from this work, which was published in June 2011, will be considered as part of this initiative.  I think the approach of identifying barriers to progress could be a relevant approach for the case studies.

Wednesday, 27 March 2013

IUCN UK Peatland Programme Conference Sept 2013


Natural England: Upland Evidence Review


The Upland Evidence Review organised by Natural England has been considering five topics:
  • The impacts of tracks on the integrity and hydrological function of blanket peat
  • Restoration of degraded blanket bog
  • The effects of managed burning on upland peatland biodiversity, carbon and water
  • Upland Hay Meadows: What management regimes maintain the diversity of meadow flora and populations of breeding birds?
  • Impact of moorland grazing and stocking rates
These are pretty meaty topics and it is clear that Natural England, and everyone who has supported the process, has been amazed by the amount of work involved.  I have been part of the Review Group that considered tracks, and I feel that I got off lightly when compared with the amount of work involved with some of the other topics.

I attended a workshop in York, yesterday, which was the first opportunity for Natural England to present the reports to those who have contributed to them. Some are nearly complete (the Tracks report is in this category!) but others still need a lot of work.

I was heartened by the approach that is being adopted. There was talk about  the need for: an integrated approach to upland management, flexibility, matching prescriptions to the needs of the land and there was an acceptance that some of the advice that has been provided by NE in the past may not have been supported by evidence. These are difficult steps for any organisation to make, and Natural England are to be commended for even considering them.

For me, the next steps are the most interesting: taking the findings from the Review Reports and feeding them into a review of Natural England's advice and policy.  This is when the effort that has gone into preparing the reports will start to make a difference on the ground. We should not forget that this is what matters and where the effort will be judged.

The process to feed the Reports into Advice & Policy will be taking place through 2013 and I will be watching closely, while supporting the work, to see what changes are introduced.  This will involve a different team within Natural England and meanwhile the Evidence Team will be working on the next round of Evidence Reviews.  There is even talk of including a review of heather beetle!  Watch this space!

Assistance for Arran & Argyll - tracked vehicles



I relay a message from Teresa Dougall from Scottish Land & Estates, which needs no explanation:

Gregor Caldwell of the Scottish Government Rural Payments and Inspections Directorate (SGRPID) Ayr office telephoned this morning asking us for help with the emergency situation in Arran and Argyll. This request has come direct from Richard Lochhead, Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment, and Drew Sloan, Chief Agricultural Officer. As you will by now have seen on the national and regional news, drifting snow on Arran and Argyll has cut off sheep and farmers are unable to access the hills.

Although some Local Authority roads are now open, there are real access problems to farms and hills. The local farmers have identified a need for ATV tracked vehicles and possibly snow bikes to take feeding out to stranded animals on hills but all of the available machines seem to be in service with the power companies.

A Scottish Government stakeholder group is to be convened from Edinburgh and Scottish Land & Estates will have an involvement in this – this will be to consider the details, logistics and costs of the operation. But, in the meantime, we need to identify members with available vehicles at short notice to help.

If you have an available vehicle, please email me on Teresa.dougall@scottishlandandestates.co.uk as soon as possible or telephone 01292 267074.

Your assistance would be appreciated.

Kind regards

Teresa

Monday, 25 March 2013

Sheep Ticks and the Tick Bite Prevention Week

To coincide with the Tick Bite Prevention Week, 24-30 March 2013, the Trust has published its latest Members' Briefing that covers Sheep Ticks.

Sheep ticks are a curse on ground-nesting moorland birds, on wild moorland animals and on domestic livestock but more significantly the diseases they carry are a threat to humans, and in the UK, this is principally from Lyme Disease.

The Brucellosis and Associated Diseases Awareness-UK (BADA-UK to their friends) has organised their annual Tick Bite Prevention Week.  For more information, see the announcement that BADA-UK has circulated.  Wendy Fox is the chairman of BADA-UK and she is partially sighted and paralysed from the waist down as a result of Lyme disease.  This is not a disease that happens elsewhere, it is here in the UK, now.

Bracken litter is ideal habitat for sheep ticks and this explains my direct interest in the subject.  Many bracken beds are located beside footpaths, which give ticks easy access to humans, and many domestic stock and wild animals use these same beds for shelter, access and grazing.  An adult red deer can carry 5,000 sheep ticks!

Bracken control reduces the amount of tick-favourable habitat and therefore the threat from the diseases they carry.  The reprieve for asulam, during 2013 at least, will allow important bracken control programmes to continue and even allow new ones to start.

Against this background, the Tick Bite Prevention Week is timely and worthy of support.  For details of funraising for BADA-UK see the Wagathon post, below.

Moorland Fire Fighting Insurance



It may seem to be rather strange to be thinking about fire, and insurance for the damage it can cause, while those parts of the country that are not covered in snow are being deluged under heavy rain.  However, at this time of year, I am very conscious that conditions can change quickly, and soggy conditions can soon change to produce vegetation that is too dry to burn safely.

Lycetts insurance brokers can provide moorland fire fighting insurance cover and they will donate 10% of the premium payable  for cover taken out by members of the Trust. 

It this is of interest, there is a link on the Reading Room page of the HT website that takes you to the details of the scheme on the Lycetts website.

Friday, 22 March 2013

Country Market & Sporting Sale 2013 is live!


This year's Country Market & Sporting Sale is now live online and the bidding has started.  Click on the logo to go straight to the auction website.  This tells you all about the Sale, provides details of all the Lots, tells you how to bid and explains why it is important to the Trust.

It is also a lot of fun for us to be doing something different, although the face and voice of the Sale, Clara Jackson, will be less convinced about the fun side today, as she has been slaving to get everything ready for you.  Please feel free to reward her efforts by entering into the spirit of the Sale and bidding frantically for the Lots.

There is a newsletter that you can circulate to your friends (and enemies?!). Needless to say, we will provide plenty of reminders as the clock ticks down to the close of the Sale at 12 noon on Friday, 3rd May. Happy bidding!