Tuesday, 18 June 2013

Heather Trust Annual Report

The Annual Report is published in early August each year and it is aimed primarily at members.  However, we also circulate copies to people who support us and have an interest in the work we do.  We are in full production mode at the moment and this is a lot of work for us to do, but as ever I am very grateful for the contributions we are receiving from guest authors we have invited to contribute an article.

The first half of the report is the relatively mundane report on the Trust's activities, but the second half gets more interesting with the guest articles introducing a wide range of topics.  We publish the guest articles, with authors' permission, on the web site at about the time of the AGM in early October, and you can get a feel for the type of articles by looking at last year's articles on the website.

We would welcome any suggestions for additional articles (if they can be produced quickly) - it's a quick, easy and cheap way of getting your views into print.  If anyone is feeling left out of the distribution of the Annual Report, the solution is simple - become a member.  It's easy!

Monday, 17 June 2013

Phytophthora Ramorum in action

Many may think this disease only happens on a small scale to someone else.  The photo that I took last week shows part of a large area of damaged larch trees on land owned by the Forestry Commission at Glen Trool in Galloway.  It is a murky photo as it was taken on a murky day.  All the trees will have to be clear felled, which is the only defence against this disease.  Other types of the disease are out and about and if you think you ought to know more about the phytophthora diseases have a look at the Members' Briefings on the Trust's website.  So far the disease is not affecting heather, but it might do.

Friday, 14 June 2013

Peatland Restoration on Dartmoor

The peatland restoration message appears to be causing some indigestion on Dartmoor.  See the article from the Western Morning News, which highlights the concerns of the Dartmoor Society about the impact of the  ongoing restoration work on 20,000 acres of Dartmoor.

I can understand the concerns.  Marching over sensitive habitats with heavy equipment is not everyone's idea of conservation, but I believe that the end justifies the means.  Clearly, communication needs to take place to try and resolve the differences and confirm that the long-term benefits of rewetting justify the need for short-term intervention.

Tuesday, 11 June 2013

Knowledge for Wildfire

I am pleased to be on the Steering Group of the NERC funded Knowledge for Wildfire (KfWf) project, which is getting into its stride.  It is a successor to the FIRES Seminar series that took place 2008 - 2009, and in general this project aims to assist the management of wildfire risk in the UK at all stages from prevention to response and recovery, and more specifically to:

Join up emerging cross-sector, cross-disciplinary interests in wildfire;
Apply and adapt NERC's fire-related research to improve the evidence base for managing wildfire risk; and
Facilitate new partnership research and knowledge exchange projects to fill knowledge gaps.

To provide context there are some interesting satellite images of April's conflagration in NW Scotland, and this provides a demonstration of the information sources that are available.  We need to develop our use of this information so that it can be used in real time, rather than just when we are at the 'lessons learned' stage after another bout of wildfires.  This project will help.

This is a UK project and I will be keen that the project feeds into the Scottish Wildfire Forum.  I have been asked to attend a meeting with the Scottish Fire & Rescue Service in advance of organising a meeting that I hope will wake the Forum from its current dormancy.

I am attending a Steering Group meeting for the KfWf project this week and this will be followed by a meeting to discuss fire intensity and the implications for managing wild and prescribed fire.

Wednesday, 5 June 2013

To demonstrate or not to demonstrate

The Trust has considerable experience in organising and running demonstration events (we ran 22 separate events in one year alone!) and I believe that it is an under-rated method of communication.

I attended a Predation-Prey Associations workshop in Dunkeld, yesterday, that was organised by SNH (see the post on the Moorland Forum blog).  How best to capture practical experience of this topic and how to communicate the findings of a revised report was considered.  There was some support for using demonstration events for this purpose, and this was music to my ears.

I would like to see this idea developed further and it would combine with the interest being expressed in using demonstration events as part of the development of the Scottish Land Use Strategy Action Plan that will be considered at a workshop on 25 June.

So why do I like the concept of demonstration events?  There are many possible forms, but I believe that events can provide a unique opportunity to develop discussion amongst a diverse range of people in a non-confrontational way.  A 'talk & walk' format can include discussion on the ground, and I am fond of saying that the issues often come into perspective when standing on 'the purple stuff'.

The format provides an opportunity to establish and maintain communication with the people who manage the land, and local communities, who may not be members of the groups of 'usual suspects' that attend meetings.  Getting a diverse mix of people away from their ivory towers, computers and PowerPoint projectors, and perhaps getting them slightly wet and cold, can really help to focus minds and identify areas of consensus.

As a development of the concept, I believe that there is an argument to establish a small number of venues in each part of the country to represent a range of conditions.  The most appropriate venue could be used for each event and people would look for events that were relevant to their interests.  Several topics could be covered in an event to increase its appeal.

There would be benefit in not holding single, one-off events, as a series of events would allow confidence in the process and momentum to build.  When I ran demonstration events on four sites across England & Wales for Defra over several years, I knew I was making progress when people started contacting me to ask when the next event would take place.  Then the funding ran out and momentum dissipated!

I am not suggesting setting up expensive demonstration sites, the aim would be to demonstrate work that was already taking place or features that were already present, but some facilitation funding would be required to organise events and to fund external contributors.

With proper management I cannot see how such events cannot provide an invaluable opportunity to generate discussion and offer value for money.  We must not forget, that all the research or policy instruments are of no value unless there is communication to allow managers of the land to understand them.  People are important: do we put enough effort into thinking about how we can communicate our messages that we spend so much time developing?

Tuesday, 4 June 2013

Back in the Saddle: an Update

A slice of holiday and a busy period leading up to it has served to introduce a gap into this blog, but I am back restored, refreshed and re-focused, so will now pick up this blog again to bring followers up-to-date with the tales of everyday activity at The Heather Trust.

It is a fact of life in this fast-moving electronic age, that taking your foot off the throttle for even a short period means that on return there is a mountain to climb to get back on top of things.  I was away for 10 days, and even then thanks to electronic communications I was able to keep in contact for the first few days while stormbound in a WiFi equipped Danish yacht marina (but that's another story...).  This link allowed me to eat into the list of issues that I did not quite get finished before catching the ferry, but even so it is amazing how much can happen in a little over a week.

I am climbing fast and hope to be back on top of things shortly, but bear with me while this blog picks up on a few thing that took place while I was away.

Asulam & Bracken Control
The Notice of Authorisation was issued by the Chemicals Regulation Directorate on 20 May and this means that it is now legal to sell, transfer and promote the use asulam for bracken control.  The application period starts on 1 July and will continue until 18 September.  A use-up period will follow and this will allow application programmes to be completed and the product to be returned to the supplier or destroyed until the end of the period on 31 October.  After 31 October it will become illegal to store asulam again.

I am hoping for willing end-users and a good application season to justify all the expense and effort that has gone into getting to this stage.

Heather Trust AGM & Discussion Meeting
We have been working hard to organise the AGM in an interesting, original location and sifting through diaries and other commitments to come up with the best venue and date.  I think we have found  it.

The AGM and the associated Discussion Meeting will be held in Pickering, North Yorkshire, on 2 October 2013.

More details will follow.  All members will be welcome to attend and we will also be inviting supporters who are in reach of Pickering to join us.

Scottish Game Fair, Scone, 5-7 July
We will be present on all three days of the Game Fair and will be working on the GWCT stand to promote moorland management activity.  We will also be giving our Heather Beetle Survey a push and would be delighted to see anyone who is passing, especially if you wish to tell us about your experience of heather beetle.  Reports from the lucky ones who have not had a brush with heather beetle will be just as valuable as we try to generate a picture of where the outbreaks are located across the UK.

Scotland's Moorland Forum
Anne has been busy setting up the Forum's Summer Meeting which takes place on Friday (7 June).  This year the Forum is being hosted by the John Muir Trust and we will be given a view of their form of management at their new Wild Space Centre in Pitlochry and afterwards on Schiehallion.  These meetings are icebergs: there is such a large amount of information to cover that to get through it without members suffering 'death by PowerPoint' a lot of work has to take place in advance to get the information into a form that we can run through quickly.  We are now all set and ready for the off on Friday.

I will keep this blog going as a record of what we are up to.  But right now it is time to don my Scotland's Moorland Forum hat and prepare for a meeting organised by SNH to consider Predator-Prey relationships in Dunkeld.

Friday, 31 May 2013

Natural England - Uplands Evidence Review

The five reports from the NE Uplands Evidence Review have been published and the next phase to translate the evidence into advice has already started.  This second phase is arguably the most interesting and the aim is for this to be completed by the end of the year.  

I plan to work engage with other organisations to help develop the guidance that flows from these reviews.  It is an ideal opportunity for the industry to help Natural England develop guidance that will be appropriate and relevant to the management of the English moorlands and uplands.

The next tranche of Evidence Reviews are being planned.  I am delighted that heather beetle is likely to be one of the topics. Naturally, I would like to think that the Trust's interest has been instrumental in getting this topic included in the next round of reviews, but the most important fact is that the heather beetle threat will be recognised and treated with respect.

Natural England has circulated the following letter about the topic reports:








Natural England has been undertaking a review of Uplands Evidence and we are now ready to publish our findings. The review programme has gone through a detailed assurance process and been reviewed by Natural England’s Science Advisory Committee. This is the first of Natural England’s evidence reviews and it addresses 5 topics which were identified with stakeholder input. It reflects on areas of advice that are subject to challenge and looks at what could make a difference on the ground. The review programme forms an integral part of the Upland Delivery Review programme and follows the principles embedded in our Uplands Strategic Standard published in September 2012.

The publication includes the methodology and the assurance process as well as the five topic reviews.
The five topics were:
  • The impact of tracks on the integrity and hydrological function of blanket bog
  • Restoration of degraded blanket bog
  • The effects of managed burning on upland peatland biodiversity, carbon and water
  • Upland hay meadows: what management regimes maintain the diversity of meadow flora and populations of breeding birds
  • Moorland grazing & stocking rates
The review programme provides us with the ability to refer to the evidence underpinning the management advice we provide to our customers, some of the areas discussed were:
  • How tracks affect the structure of blanket peat and its hydrological system.
  • Is a full recovery to a functioning blanket bog possible?
  • What happens after the burning of blanket bog and wet heath, how are the habitat species affected?
  • What type and quantity of fertiliser can be applied to upland hay meadows without a negative impact on species diversity?
  • The moorland grazing & stocking rate topic has been documented it is notable however that very little (approximately 20%) of the evidence can be considered as ‘strong’ - does one size fits all?
It must be emphasised that these are just some of the discussion subjects and that the full reviews are much more detailed.

Natural England will now spend the next two months evaluating the need for amendment to the guidance we provide to our advisers. We will be consulting with you in the summer on any proposals for changes, but if you have any suggestions in the meantime please do not hesitate to contact us NE Uplands Evidence Review mailbox. Any changes agreed will be incorporated in revised guidance in the autumn, with a view to completion by the end of the year.

In future all guidance used by our staff will be made available on our internet.

Yours sincerely


Tim Hill, Chief Scientist 
Ian Fugler, Director Land Management, North & Uplands





Charles Gimingham - 90th Birthday

Professor Charles Gimingham & Malcolm Hay
Professor Charles Gimingham celebrated his 90th birthday at the end of April and I was delighted that the Heather Trust was able to mark this occasion with a small presentation to Charles made by our Chairman, Malcolm Hay.

Charles's 70th birthday, in 1993, was marked by the SNH publication 'Heaths & Moorland: Cultural Landscapes' which was the proceedings of a conference of the same name.  In the Foreword, Magnus Magnusson, then Chairman of SNH, stated that the book was 'dedicated to honouring the life's work of a living legend, Professor Charles Gimingham'.  As the founder of much of our knowledge of heathland ecology, and the man who inspired several generations of ecologists, I can think of no better description.

Charles's activities did not stop with his 70th birthday.  He has remained active and was the first President of the Trust for three years from 2004.  His support helped to raise our profile to new heights.


Saturday, 18 May 2013

The Wildfire Threat from Sky Lanterns

In my capacity as Vice-Chairman of the England & Wales Wildfire Forum, I contributed to the consultation about the threat posed by sky lanterns that was carried out for Defra by ADAS.  The consultation also covered helium balloons but my interest did not go beyond sky lanterns.  The report from the consultation has now been published and I am disappointed that Defra has not decided to take any positive action.

My concern stems from the wanton release of sky lanterns without any consideration being given to where they might land.  I accept that they look impressive, but I cannot accept that this is not without impact and cost on unconnected parties.  The ingestion of the remains by livestock has proved to be fatal, but of even more significance is the threat that lanterns pose through acting as ignition sources for wildfires.

In theory, the sky lantern stays airborne until the candle burns out and the lift of the hot gases is lost.  However, it has been shown that the canopies of sub-standard have failed which allows the lighted candle to fall to the ground.  This is a source of ignition that has caused wildfires with the associated threat to life and property and the increase in workload for the Fire & Rescue Services. this is a high price to pay for enjoyment.

The Farmers Guardian has published an article today that expresses concern about the lack of action from Defra to tackle this problem, and the comments from readers of the paper tell their own story.  An interesting comment is that if people were found dumping litter in the countryside they could be prosecuted but somehow sky lanterns are acceptable.  As the Farmers Guardian points out, sky lanterns have been banned in some countries and common sense would suggest that this at least ought to be considered in the UK.   I understand that even though most of the sky lanterns are manufactured in China, they have been banned in this country.

As an example of the absurdity of the current situation, in Dorset, the FRS reported that a lighted sky lantern drifted in through an open hotel window and started a fire.  While I may be viewed as a spoil sport, I find it difficult to support the indiscriminate release of incendiary devices without adequate precautions to make sure they do not cause damage.

Sunday, 12 May 2013

Comments & Feedback

This blog has been receiving the attention of someone who needs to get a life and stop circulating spam messages.  It is a fascinating study on life that people have time and energy for such activity - what a waste!

To avoid cluttering up my inbox with the results of this activity I have turned off the comments function for the moment.  This does not mean that I will not welcome any feedback that posts on this blog generate, and please pass these back to me via the contact facility on the Heather Trust's website.  So far at least this appears to be able to defeat the spammers.

Saturday, 11 May 2013

Unsold Lots are available from Country Market & Sporting Sale




The Sale closed on 3 May but some unsold Lots will remain available until 17 May 2013.

Bidding for these Lots is a doddle - just log on to the Sale's website, and follow your fingers.

We will be grateful for your support.

Wildfire Danger in the South Pennines

The Grough carried a good article about recent wildfires in the hills above Littleborough, Todmorden, Hebden Bridge and Cragg Vale and provides a good advert for the Fire Operations Group and to the benefits of partnership working.  The reference to the value being placed on the uplands for conservation and habitat as well as in economic terms is relevant and useful.

The article is well worth a read

Tuesday, 30 April 2013

Burning for grouse alters upland stream ecology

This is a report on recently published research by the University of Leeds.  The title is rather more emotive than the report, and it is encouraging to note the reference to the need to take economic factors into account.

Although there are obvious concerns about the impact of burning on peatland and the downstream effects on water quality, I am more concerned about the impact of bad burning practices and wildfire.  I believe that use of best practice burning techniques by skilled moorland managers will produce the best results for grouse, heather, peatland, water and other ecosystems.

Country Market & Sporting Sale - the final stages


The Sale closes at 12 noon on 3 May.

We are now in the exciting, critical stages of this year's Sale and we look forward to receiving your bids.  Don't miss out on some exciting opportunities - some of the Lots have been made offered specially for our Sale and are not normally available.

The fascinating range of Lots is fully available and bidding is a doddle - just log on to the Sale's website and follow your fingers.

We will be grateful for your support.

Monday, 29 April 2013

Heather management: burning and cutting

Richard May on cut heather (Patrick Laurie)
The merits of burning and/or cutting heather have been debated in bars, houses and on moors since the management of moorland began.  Cutting is perhaps the new kid on the block, as fire has been managing heather since time began and as a result, heather is described as a fire-adapted plant.

At the Heather Trust, we have revived interest in this debate, as we have been made aware of the work that Richard May, a member of the Board, has been doing in the Peak District.  It was time to investigate further, and Patrick Laurie set off last week with this as an objective, in addition to catching up with the work that has been taking place on the moors that are contributing to the restoration trial after heather beetle.  Patrick has set out his thoughts from his visit on his own Blog.

Starting with Patrick's thoughts, I have started to list out the issues we could consider as part of this review and it has quickly become extensive.  There will be more issues, but these are the first ideas:

  • Does burning aid regeneration of heather from seed - the smoke is thought to condition the seed to increase the rate of germination?
  • Cutting does not work where the ground is unsuitable - too steep, on broken / rocky ground, where there is no access, or where the ground is too wet.
  • Cutting can achieve a fine mosaic that would be difficult to replicate by burning.
  • What are the impacts of a fine mosaic on grouse and other species?
  • What are the merits of cutting and leaving the brash, against cutting and removing?
  • What is the effect of age of heather on the relevant merits of the different techniques?
  • How is the impact on the landscape assessed?
  • The impact of burning on water quality, especially on peat soils, has been extensively researched, but is there an impact from cutting?
  • The relative costs should be considered - burning requires a team of people, while cutting can be carried out by one person and one machine - "burn heather or burn diesel".
  • Cutting does not carry a risk of wildfire.
  • How can cutting can be best used in support of burning?
  • How do we cater for the fact that 'every moor is different'?

I plan to work up these ideas into an article, or even a series of articles, that we will publish in our Annual Report.  To make this work as well-informed as possible, I hope to harness some other sources of information that include Professor Rob Marrs, our President; Richard May for input from his work in the Peak District; and possibly other organisations such as GWCT and British Moorlands.

Dick Bartlett of British moorlands is a member of the Trust and is based near Aberlour in Morayshire.  During the Cairngorms Land Management Forum meeting, last week (see separate post) he was expounding an approach to moorland management for grouse that  involved cutting a network of narrow strips through heather.  This could provide some useful input to our review.

Thursday, 25 April 2013

Peatland at the Cairngorms Land Management Forum

It was a full house in the ballroom at Glen Tanar Estate on Deeside today.  Judging by the quality and quantity of the attendance, the Land Management Forum, which is run jointly by the Cairngorms National Park and Scottish Land & Estates, is gaining momentum and achieving credibility.  I welcome this as I have been to several meetings of previous incarnations of this Forum, which have been a bit dour by comparison.  Today's meeting provided a good opportunity to meet many HT members and supporters.

I was invited to speak about peatland management, and explain my view of the future in language that I hope the landowners and managers could understand and appreciate.  In my view, the biggest issue that will make people sit up and pay attention is the possibility of peatland restoration and management providing an additional income stream.  I attempted to explain that I see the awakening interest in peatland restoration and management as an opportunity, not a threat.

I understand the cynicism that some people express, but my argument to them is that they should at least keep an open mind while the options are explored.  They might be pleasantly surprised!

Tuesday, 23 April 2013

England & Wales Wildfire Forum

Photo: Andy Law

Although the were some nasty incidents in South Wales and on Dartmoor, the worst of the wildfires have passed by England and Wales, this year.  However, as I have reported on extensively, I believe that the wildfires in Scotland, this year, have highlighted the need for an effective Wildfire Forum.  I see a Forum as providing an umbrella organisation to bring together the Fire Service, the landowners and land managers, the practitioners and fire researchers to provide some cohesion, which otherwise appears to be sadly lacking.

Against this background, I attended the meeting of the England & Wales Wildfire Forum, earlier this month.  There was some useful discussion around wildfire issues, but I was particularly interested in the proposals to review the governance of the Forum.  This is hardly riveting stuff, but unless we get it right everything else suffers.

The current chairman of the Forum is the Chief Fire Officer of Northumberland FRS and although the CFO has changed, Northumberland FRS has provided the chairman for the last seven years.  The chairman has indicated that he feels it is time for the chair to be rotated.  As Vice-Chairman, he has asked whether I would be interested in taking on this role but I have asked that before this is put to members of the Forum, we carry out a review of the EWWF. There are three issues that need to be addressed.

For the Forum to be effective, I believe it is essential that we have good access to government, and the point of contact is the Dept for Communities & Local Government (DCLG).  Without this contact, there is a danger that the EWWF will be unable to have any influence on policy.  We need to establish how this is to be achieved.

Another issue to be explored is the future of the funding for the secretariat function.  Currently, this is provided by Northumberland FRS, and if the FRS is unable to guarantee that funding ail continue to be available, Forum members must either fund the Forum themselves, or find an alternative source of funds.  Either way, without resources the long-term future of the Forum is in doubt.  Without an effective secretariat to deliver and chase action, there is a danger that nothing happens between meetings.

A final issue is the continuation of the link to the Wildfire Group that is run by the Chief Fire Officers' Association.  This is much more an internal FRS group, but there are concerns that there is duplication and a danger of giving a mixed message to government.

I accept that this is remarkably boring stuff but exactly the same debate needs to take place in Scotland as we move to revitalise the Scottish Wildfire Forum.

Thursday, 18 April 2013

Wildfire 2013 - 22-23 October - Details announced


Wildfire 2013 represents an opportunity for all those involved in the prevention of, and response to, wildfires to come together to share best practice, hear from researchers working on the subject and meet providers of wildfire related equipment and services.

More details and booking information can be found here.

This year’s event will be held at The Vale Resort www.vale-hotel.com in the Vale of Glamorgan.

Monday, 15 April 2013

Country Market & Sporting Sale - the countdown begins


Now that the Easter holidays are behind us, there is a little less than three weeks until the close of this year's Sale at 12 noon on Friday, 3rd May.  There has been some bidding on some of the Lots but the field is still wide open for anyone who wants to buy something.

If you are looking for a bit of light entertainment, may I recommend a quick browse through the wide range of exciting Lots that can be viewed on the dedicated website?  You never know, you may find just what you did not know you were looking for!  If not, you might like to recommend the Sale to someone you know.

As well as being a lot of fun for us (as well as hard work) your support for the Sale provides the Trust with the income we need to carry out a large amount of advocacy work in all parts of the UK to benefit our uplands and moorlands.

Thursday, 11 April 2013

Your Heather Trust Needs You


The Heather Trust has a small but important band of members who come from all walks of life.  The members support the Trust's work and give me justification for getting up in the morning.  Being a smaller organisation than some, I am able to provide our members with a much more personal service.  To me, a member is not just a number, to be contacted for a subscription renewal or for cash, you are a highly valued part of the Trust.

Understandably, as we all lead busy lives, I do not get a lot of input from our band of members, but those who do contact the office can be guaranteed of a personal service.  Your input can make a difference.

The benefit of a small organisation is that we are light on our feet and are able to respond quickly and   I would like to think that I can say 'yes' or 'no' to any proposal almost immediately.  Compare the response to a question about supporting one of our initiatives that I received yesterday from another organisation:  we "would like to be involved in this line of work but as you can imagine this would need to be resourced into our work year through the hierarchy".

If you have not already seen it have a look at the new website which gives you a feel for the work we are involved with. The Reading Room with its new Member Briefings is also worth a look

Non-members read on:
If you have read this you must have an interest in the work of The Heather Trust, but may I now  encourage you to think about joining the band of members. Subscriptions start at £40 p.a. for individuals and there is a give-away rate for students and gamekeepers of £12 p.a.

Inevitably, all the details you need are on the Membership page of the website.

I look forward to welcoming you as a member of the Trust.